This was disappointing because they didn't have the pumpkin carving which is what made this show unique. We see a thousand different baking shows, and there's already a Halloween baking championship, which is what they've watered this down to. I did like the new judges - they should keep them, and I prefer the absence of the "class clown" hosting the show and failing at humor - he was never funny, just childish. Having said all that, the pumpkin carving - which is unique to Halloween - is missing which makes this new show a failure. I hope they learn their lesson and bring back the pumpkin carving, otherwise there's just no point.