This has got to be the first time ever that a movie pitted two chefs against each other, and they ended up falling in love. Ha! Just kidding. Hallmark premiered Just Add Romance in March of 2019, and it's only the umpteenth time in which a movie cribbed this shopworn plot. But, as they say, what does it matter if it's the same old story as long as the execution's good? It's an axiom that applies here.
Here's another saying: never trust a skinny cook. Except, to look at the svelte marvels that are Carley and Jason, why, they must be the worst cooks ever. Never mind. Carley (Meghann Fahy) and Jason (Luke MacFarlane) met some years ago while attending a culinary school in New York. Even back then, they had this good-natured yet caustic back-and-forth; they simply liked to give each other the business. One day, Jason stopped showing up.
Maybe some plot spoilers.
Three years pass, and we get to the meat of the plot. And the venue's shifted from New York to Chicago. It's Jason's home; it's where he's head chef of a restaurant of which management insists that the house recipes be adhered to precisely, no room for experimenting. That sort of suits Jason fine, seeing as how he's a traditionalist in the kitchen.
Conversely, Carley Benson cooks by instinct. She improvises. She's adventurous in the kitchen. While Jason measures meticulously, she eyeballs. Her motto is "Memorable requires risk." Carley is also now in Chicago where she head chefs at Cafe Pierre. I can't remember what Jason's eatery is called, but it's probably something not as fancy-pants-sounding. Like maybe Jason's Steak & Butter Shack.
What are the odds that these two who hadn't seen each other for years should end up on the same cooking reality show? For this season, Kitchen Showdown has gone to Chicago and taken six of the best local chefs in the city as its contestants. It'll be a six-day shoot, six different challenges with one competitor eliminated after each round, with the last chef standing getting to open their own restaurant. And, more than the romance that "unexpectedly" surfaces to spice up Kitchen Showdown, what I really enjoyed was how the plot contrived to present interesting aspects of the reality show, whether it's the nature of the cooking challenges themselves - the blind segment, cooking for your family, etc. - or the savory meals that end up being showcased (I'm a simple guy; my favorite were the pizza puffs).
Gratifyingly, the other contestants get enough character work that their interactions with the leads mean something and, later, you feel for them when they get bounced to the judge's dismissive catchphrase, "It's time to leave the kitchen." As for the two leads, there's not much more to Carley and Jason past the tension between them. Okay, there is a sub-plot concerning Carley's uncertainty in her dealings with her imposing father, the celebrated five-star chef, Kenneth Benson (Malcolm Stewart). As for Jason, he's just a chill guy, even if he does tend to stubbornly stick to the recipes. There's not much of a character arc for him. It's actually Carley who's bothered that Jason doesn't ever step outside the box. Meghann Fahy and Luke MacFarlane work in enough chemistry that, coupled with several interesting plot elements, and how tasty the various dishes look, and how I just grin whenever Carley bends the recipes, Just Add Romance ends up a very diverting and, dare I say, savory watch. Yeah, this deserves repeat viewings. And I appreciate the random cooking tips tossed in. Like, I now know to make sure the batter doesn't overwhelm the shrimp. I do like shrimp.