To calculate the overall star rating and percentage breakdown by star, we don’t use a simple average. Instead, our system considers things like how recent a review is and if the reviewer bought the item on Amazon. It also analyzes reviews to verify trustworthiness.
I wasn't sure what to expect from a YA Jeff Vandermeer book, but essentially this is over six-hundred pages of Jeff Vandermeer. If you like Jeff Vandermeer's other books, you'll probably love this. If you don't know who Jeff Vandermeer is, you should know that unlike some writers of epic young adult fantasy, Jeff Vandermeer is an excellent prose stylist. He's also incredibly imaginative, and leans into the weird pretty hard.
This book, like all his books, has its own style. It's told in a sort of British-clever voice, and is at once that, and a send-up of that. There are also sections of this book that are just beautifully written, and caused me to go back over them just to see how they were put together to create the effect they have. There are plenty of likeable and strange characters, and the world being set up is full of unexpected surprises.
Although this book in some sense has the spine of a typical fantasy quest, the details and rules of the world being built here really distinguish it from other fantasy. This book features talking marmots, Alistair Crowley, the disembodied head of Napoleon, and a slew of other characters I don't want to spoil. As I understand it, A Peculiar Peril is either the first part of a duology, or the first two parts of a tetrology. In any case, the book comes to a satisfying close, but there are plenty of interesting plot threads that need resolving.
VanderMeer lets his freak flag fly in this novel of adventure, intrigue, and... marmots. A peculiar peril draws from many classic fantasies but is also wholly unique (enter bodiless Napoleon as a secondary character). My only qualm is that occasionally, early on the dialogue felt forced, and in the middle of the book, the plot seemed to move along a little slowly. I can state however, that I have never read a book quite like it. A Peculiar Peril is funny, and although there are multiple beheadings, and the wholesale slaughter of rabid chipmunks (to power giant war machines of course), it almost always feels lighthearted. I do recommend, but just prepare yourself for unyielding weirdness.
Great book! Haven't finished it yet but it was unexpectedly signed by the fantastic author which was a nice bonus having pre-ordered it. Otherwise, so far it is excellent writing that is to be expected at this point of Jeff VanderMeer. So far the book is PG and is probably a great introduction to this genre for anyone above age 13.
Where to begin with this book? As a long time fan of VanderMeer, I'm one to pick up anything new he publishes, but had no idea what to expect from this first YA outing. Well to be clear from the start, it's YA in style and presentation only - there's humour, and absurdity, and a fantasy setting with talking animals, but it's all wrapped around emotionally deep characters and an incredibly complex narrative that continues the same themes of authoritarian power structures and the environment that drive the majority of VanderMeer's fiction.
This is a brilliant story, reminiscent of the fantasy worlds of Walter Moer's, but with more deapth and breadth and utter insanity to keep your turning the page for the entire 650 - page wild ride.
Reviewed in the United States on December 17, 2020
Fans of Jeff VanderMeer won’t think twice about falling into his latest world, a 650-page YA novel titled, A Peculiar Peril. When protagonist Jonathan Lambshead arrives at the mansion he inherited from his grandfather, a wild adventure begins featuring a gateway to place called Aurora, a different version of Earth. On the adventure, we find talking animals, and versions of Napoleon, Charlemagne and Kafka. Jonathan comes to appreciate his role to keep Aurora and Earth separated. The strange characters are delightful, especially the talking marmots, the fantasy enjoyable, and the writing weird and lighthearted.