Top critical review
Nearly perfect match for my needs
Reviewed in the United States on December 21, 2019
Rewriting my original review, reducing to 3*s based on lack of durability in less than a year of use. While they are still great for light weight, stay-open and stay put for loading, the textile of the bag is poor quality that degrades, disintegrates very quickly in sunlight. So, while cost as a disposable garden aid is still reasonable, don't expect these to last a long time.
Original review: Have only had one of the bags in use for a few weeks but it's already proved to be exactly what I hoped and more in function and quality. Note the shape of this big bag, that it is wider than it is deep was just what I needed. So many 'pop-up' garden bags are tall narrow designs that would not work for me. I bought these to replace the great old canvas bag that I loved until the straps disintegrated. These polypropelene bags are crisp enough to stand tall without collapsing which is another benefit and one you might not expect since they don't have the spring coil that pop-up bags do. I like these very much. They are quite large so keep that in mind when loading so you can still haul them around!