I had to watch all the way to the end, like a train wreck. I gave it 1 star but now I'm changing it to 2 because it's crossed over from bad to worse and back to entertaining again just to see how bad it is.
Everyone has already mentioned the wig. I usually don't notice that kind of thing, but I noticed. Bad green screen during the car scenes. So bad it was distracting. The eyebrows that you can't unsee.
The Amish: there's just 2 Amish characters? Very weird. And Sarah, the Amish girl, apparently won't speak using contractions? I googled it, and that's not a thing. Super awkward dialogue. I feel like they did a real disservice to Amish people and just used their religion to prove how "middle of nowhere" the character had gone. In one scene the Amish girl has ridden in a car to buy groceries (questionable) and among the (only 2 bags of) groceries is a loaf of bread. Really?
In one scene, she turns the nice guy down for a dinner date and tells him that she isn't looking to date right now. A couple scenes later, the SAME DAY, she accepts the hunky guy's offer for dinner, and that's perfectly fine. And she has a glass of wine at the early dinner which is not a date.
Super predictable plot, bad script writing, bad acting. Would give it a C+ if it had been an assignment for a high school theater student.