This collection of 24 picks, in three thicknesses (no x-heavies), comes in a limited color variety. Now, I don't care about the color of the pick (unless it's completely obnoxious) and the selection in this pack is good enough for me (I know some reviewers want more variety). The split of thicknesses is fine as well. And the quality of the picks is what you'd expect: a nice Fender product although calling the picks "premium" is a stretch.
I do think they are overpriced. It comes to about forty-five cents each! I can get them at the guitar store for less. Had I calculated in advance I wouldn't have ordered these. I'll go three stars because I just don't think this pack provides enough value.