I bought 2 pairs of these. Black pair was in original plastic with tag. Blue pair was a repackage with no tag. I opened the plastic & the strong odor of FISH hit me in the face! Crotch stank to high heaven. Someone clearly wore them and either had bad hygiene or sweat a lot and then returned them. I contacted the seller and they apologized but couldn't do anything as it was fulfilled by Amazon. So, I returned both pair because that is just unacceptable. I am afraid to re-order as I might get the same rancid shorts back. So disappointed. I use Amazon for pretty much everything but groceries and this is the 3rd time I've gotten something that was obviously a return. The other two had things like a chewed up tag or animal hair on it. I can deal with that, but someone else's stink is just unsanitary.
I did try on the new ones (WITH UNDERWEAR) and they do not cover the bellybutton. I am a curvy size 10 with a short torso and sized up/got the XL based on reviews. They fit super comfortably but were not true high waist.