Holds my iPhone 11 Pro Max with thickish case securely without having to fight to insert or remove. Also held my iPhone 7+ with OtterBox as nicely until my recent upgrade. Magnetic flap is secure and snug with perfect alignment even with the thicker case. Horizontal design means I don't have to endure kidney jabs every time I sit in the car. Keeps my phone in easy reach to remove it when I forget to place it on the dash magnet mount -- even after I've belted in.
Some have complained about the belt clip "catching" when trying to slip a belt through the loops. I use a web belt with a roughish end (melted), and have found it quite simple to lift the tough nylon clip slightly with my thumb -- and my belt slides right through.
Four stars as it's an excellent value that will serve me for much time to come, but it's NOT leather as advertised. This was only a minor disappointment as I suspected as much (based on the price point) before I purchased. I feel the seller should correct this -- it doesn't need to be real leather to be a good product.