My 4 year old son loves these books and he likes to talk about the things David did wrong that got him into trouble. My only criticism would be the page where the teacher says (you need to use the restroom) "Again??" Kids at the young end of this book's suggested age range shouldn't feel worried about asking their teacher to go to the restroom any time they need it. I always tell my son that when we reach this page. Other than that, we love reading these books... again and again.