Amazon.com: Customer reviews: Elevating Child Care: A Guide to Respectful Parenting

Top positive review

Zen approach to child care - should be mandatory reading

Reviewed in the United States on July 8, 2014

In writing this book Janet Lansbury has elevated the RIE philosophy to a whole new level. I read Magda Gerber's books when I had my first child, and I found them to promote distant childcare - at least from my perspective of a new parent entirely steeped in the Attachment Parenting (AP) philosophy (my review of the book talks at length about the differences between AP and RIE Your Self-Confident Baby: How to Encourage Your Child's Natural Abilities -- From the Very Start. I was also in love with Maria Montessori's writings advocating respect for the child, so I didn't feel Magda's books offered a novel idea.

...until AP failed me. I loved spending every second with my son, I carried him everywhere, co-slept, nursed him until he self-weaned at 3.5yo, kissed him every chance I had, obsessed over his diet and bowel movements...only to find out this was never enough. He wanted more and more and more of me, until my self-sacrifice took a toll on my health and emotions. Just as an example, leaving the house was a 1-hour ordeal that started with "mommy don't go," moved into guilt trips "mommy I cry angel tears for you when you leave," proceeded into demands for treats or toys, and culminated in a heart-wrenching scream-fest a block or so down the road for all neighbors to see (might I add, in the arms of his dad which he adored, and who quit his job to be a stay-at-home parent). We were all out of give.

Having amassed an extensive library of parenting books, I revisited some of them in search for answers. Magda's book struck me differently then. I just had to be honest with my son (I have to leave tomorrow to go to work), validate his feelings (I know you don't like me to leave, I hate to go too), and comfort him if he cried without having to stop the meltdown (I see you're sad/disappointed....). Then magic happened. I could leave the house! That elusive `more" that my son wanted from me was validation, he wanted to know that I understood what he was going through, he did not want me to never leave the house. I started to pay more attention to how *I* felt and responded to his feelings. The key was to not take his feelings personally - they were his - but to make sure they were all acceptable in my book (including hysterical crying).

When I had my second baby, I decided to give RIE a more serious try. I read Janet Lansbury's blogs, followed her advice on Facebook, and a number of very smart parents who have now become "my village". I am blown away by the results. It's true that every child is different, but I am doing things very similar this time around (I'm still nursing on demand, co-sleeping, etc., etc.). The only difference: I am paying much more attention to my child, not assuming anything until I stop, watch, and think, and offer minimal intervention when I find out the cause. For e.g., my baby fusses and cries, I go over (no, no longer running frantically fire-drill style), I calmly say: "you sound upset". Then ***I OBSERVE*****. I don't pick up, latch on, and rock around the room until the crying stops. I look for clues as to what might have upset my baby. 90% of the time involves situations for which hugs and milk are the wrong response (such as toy fell off her reach, I stopped singing, brother left the room....). And then, I don't pick up the toy and put it in her hands, I simply validate: "you're upset because the toy fell. You were having fun with it." And then DO NOTHING. Simple, right?

Another situation: 6-mo old baby is congested, and wakes up mad throughout the night because she can't breathe and she can't nurse. With the first baby, the solution was saline spray followed by the Nosefrieda (my arms and feet wrapped around my squirming child, heart aching from having to put him through that). I knew the process did not hurt one bit, because I had resorted to spraying his nose in his sleep and he didn't even wake up. With the second child, I showed her the spray bottle and simply explained what was going to happen. First few times she squirmed and cried just as hard as my boy....until I RIE-d the process further. I just put her on her bed, and did not try to subdue her at all. Just told her what I was going to do and waited for her "permission" - any sign of readiness to proceed. I sprayed, she smiled, and it was over. Husband almost fell on the floor (yes, he often had to come help me hold the kids from flailing around while I cleaned their nose, all 6ft of him).

One of Janet's first chapters gives you the keys to resolve such situations. She proposes a role reversal. Think about yourself incapacitated, and your child (or some big bulky tall person) taking care of you. They show up with strange instruments, hold you down, and proceed to insert things into your nose - your only breathing apparatus!!!! - and you gag at the feeling, but you are powerless. Wouldn't you scream and fight too? (I've read alien abduction stories that went like this...). Going back to the separation anxiety example, suppose your loved one is leaving the house for an indeterminate amount of time over which you have no control, and he looks like he can't wait to get out the door, rushing through the house collecting clothes, keys, coffee, etc., you totally invisible at best, and at worst a nuisance. Wouldn't you cry too?

This book should be read by all parents - new and seasoned. I am not advocating RIE over any other parenting philosophy (although now I strongly prefer it). I think this book is a must for showing you how to think through situations from the eyes of a child (not just telling you to do so) and giving you the tools to respond in a respectful way (in other words the `how-to' missing from the Gerber and Montessori books). In addition, the book fills a very big gap in parenting books: how to raise emotionally intelligent children. I had read all about how important emotional intelligence is, all about how empathy is a better predictor of success than IQ, all about how boys grow up emotionally illiterate, etc. I had read Freud's writings inside and out while in college and knew early experiences might doom my child to perpetual counseling. I knew ABOUT the importance of all the above, but did not know the HOW to go about raising a child who knows what they feel, and knows that whatever they feel is ok (not what they do, what they feel - not advocating permissive parenting here), and knows how they want to be treated. (My older child has coached me through my mommy-tantrums a couple of times now).

The book is a collection of Janet's blogs, so one commenter questioned the need to buy the book at all. However, once you go down the RIE path, you will probably encounter resistance because your parenting will appear odd (what do you mean, you don't shush a crying baby? "You're ok" is the wrong thing to say?!! You don't want me to say "Good job!"??). To have a book that you can hand to your husband, nanny, parent, or whoever is taking care of your child (or judging your childcare), is much more convenient than printing out or forwarding blog articles. In addition, you can choose to purchase the audio version - which is what I did. I get more "listening" time than reading time these days. As an added bonus, Janet's voice conveys warmth, confidence, and happiness - a reminder that the childrearing years are good times, not drudgery to wish away or over with. Instead, she advocates an almost Zen approach to parenting: slow down, observe, listen, and be present. Even a messy diaper change can be an opportunity to connect with your child. In today's busy life where parents focus on doing more more and more for and to their child, this book points out the benefits of doing less, but doing it with your child. I am very indebted to this lady for the amazing difference she has made in my parenting.

604 people found this helpful

Top critical review

All critical reviews›

Candace Ball

Harmful Advice

Reviewed in the United States on May 3, 2022

I was referred this book by a friend but was really disappointed only two chapters into it. I finished it but was rolling my eyes for many parts of it. I liked how she says to treat your baby as a person, give them quality time with eye contact and let them work on playing independently at home. The parts I found ridiculous were asking permission to change your baby’s diaper or pick them up. You’re supposed to tell them each step of the diaper change as you’re doing it. She also doesn’t believe in any punishments and says timeouts and spankings are going to shame your baby. This advice is so harmful because punishments are a big part of discipline and understanding consequences in life. They can be given in love and compassion if done right.

One person found this helpful

Sort by

Filter by

Filtered by

5 starClear filter

923 global ratings | 251 global reviews

There was a problem filtering reviews right now. Please try again later.

From the United States

Ivy

Zen approach to child care - should be mandatory reading

Reviewed in the United States on July 8, 2014

Verified Purchase

In writing this book Janet Lansbury has elevated the RIE philosophy to a whole new level. I read Magda Gerber's books when I had my first child, and I found them to promote distant childcare - at least from my perspective of a new parent entirely steeped in the Attachment Parenting (AP) philosophy (my review of the book talks at length about the differences between AP and RIE Your Self-Confident Baby: How to Encourage Your Child's Natural Abilities -- From the Very Start . I was also in love with Maria Montessori's writings advocating respect for the child, so I didn't feel Magda's books offered a novel idea.

...until AP failed me. I loved spending every second with my son, I carried him everywhere, co-slept, nursed him until he self-weaned at 3.5yo, kissed him every chance I had, obsessed over his diet and bowel movements...only to find out this was never enough. He wanted more and more and more of me, until my self-sacrifice took a toll on my health and emotions. Just as an example, leaving the house was a 1-hour ordeal that started with "mommy don't go," moved into guilt trips "mommy I cry angel tears for you when you leave," proceeded into demands for treats or toys, and culminated in a heart-wrenching scream-fest a block or so down the road for all neighbors to see (might I add, in the arms of his dad which he adored, and who quit his job to be a stay-at-home parent). We were all out of give.

Having amassed an extensive library of parenting books, I revisited some of them in search for answers. Magda's book struck me differently then. I just had to be honest with my son (I have to leave tomorrow to go to work), validate his feelings (I know you don't like me to leave, I hate to go too), and comfort him if he cried without having to stop the meltdown (I see you're sad/disappointed....). Then magic happened. I could leave the house! That elusive `more" that my son wanted from me was validation, he wanted to know that I understood what he was going through, he did not want me to never leave the house. I started to pay more attention to how *I* felt and responded to his feelings. The key was to not take his feelings personally - they were his - but to make sure they were all acceptable in my book (including hysterical crying).

When I had my second baby, I decided to give RIE a more serious try. I read Janet Lansbury's blogs, followed her advice on Facebook, and a number of very smart parents who have now become "my village". I am blown away by the results. It's true that every child is different, but I am doing things very similar this time around (I'm still nursing on demand, co-sleeping, etc., etc.). The only difference: I am paying much more attention to my child, not assuming anything until I stop, watch, and think, and offer minimal intervention when I find out the cause. For e.g., my baby fusses and cries, I go over (no, no longer running frantically fire-drill style), I calmly say: "you sound upset". Then ***I OBSERVE*****. I don't pick up, latch on, and rock around the room until the crying stops. I look for clues as to what might have upset my baby. 90% of the time involves situations for which hugs and milk are the wrong response (such as toy fell off her reach, I stopped singing, brother left the room....). And then, I don't pick up the toy and put it in her hands, I simply validate: "you're upset because the toy fell. You were having fun with it." And then DO NOTHING. Simple, right?

Another situation: 6-mo old baby is congested, and wakes up mad throughout the night because she can't breathe and she can't nurse. With the first baby, the solution was saline spray followed by the Nosefrieda (my arms and feet wrapped around my squirming child, heart aching from having to put him through that). I knew the process did not hurt one bit, because I had resorted to spraying his nose in his sleep and he didn't even wake up. With the second child, I showed her the spray bottle and simply explained what was going to happen. First few times she squirmed and cried just as hard as my boy....until I RIE-d the process further. I just put her on her bed, and did not try to subdue her at all. Just told her what I was going to do and waited for her "permission" - any sign of readiness to proceed. I sprayed, she smiled, and it was over. Husband almost fell on the floor (yes, he often had to come help me hold the kids from flailing around while I cleaned their nose, all 6ft of him).

One of Janet's first chapters gives you the keys to resolve such situations. She proposes a role reversal. Think about yourself incapacitated, and your child (or some big bulky tall person) taking care of you. They show up with strange instruments, hold you down, and proceed to insert things into your nose - your only breathing apparatus!!!! - and you gag at the feeling, but you are powerless. Wouldn't you scream and fight too? (I've read alien abduction stories that went like this...). Going back to the separation anxiety example, suppose your loved one is leaving the house for an indeterminate amount of time over which you have no control, and he looks like he can't wait to get out the door, rushing through the house collecting clothes, keys, coffee, etc., you totally invisible at best, and at worst a nuisance. Wouldn't you cry too?

This book should be read by all parents - new and seasoned. I am not advocating RIE over any other parenting philosophy (although now I strongly prefer it). I think this book is a must for showing you how to think through situations from the eyes of a child (not just telling you to do so) and giving you the tools to respond in a respectful way (in other words the `how-to' missing from the Gerber and Montessori books). In addition, the book fills a very big gap in parenting books: how to raise emotionally intelligent children. I had read all about how important emotional intelligence is, all about how empathy is a better predictor of success than IQ, all about how boys grow up emotionally illiterate, etc. I had read Freud's writings inside and out while in college and knew early experiences might doom my child to perpetual counseling. I knew ABOUT the importance of all the above, but did not know the HOW to go about raising a child who knows what they feel, and knows that whatever they feel is ok (not what they do, what they feel - not advocating permissive parenting here), and knows how they want to be treated. (My older child has coached me through my mommy-tantrums a couple of times now).

The book is a collection of Janet's blogs, so one commenter questioned the need to buy the book at all. However, once you go down the RIE path, you will probably encounter resistance because your parenting will appear odd (what do you mean, you don't shush a crying baby? "You're ok" is the wrong thing to say?!! You don't want me to say "Good job!"??). To have a book that you can hand to your husband, nanny, parent, or whoever is taking care of your child (or judging your childcare), is much more convenient than printing out or forwarding blog articles. In addition, you can choose to purchase the audio version - which is what I did. I get more "listening" time than reading time these days. As an added bonus, Janet's voice conveys warmth, confidence, and happiness - a reminder that the childrearing years are good times, not drudgery to wish away or over with. Instead, she advocates an almost Zen approach to parenting: slow down, observe, listen, and be present. Even a messy diaper change can be an opportunity to connect with your child. In today's busy life where parents focus on doing more more and more for and to their child, this book points out the benefits of doing less, but doing it with your child. I am very indebted to this lady for the amazing difference she has made in my parenting.

604 people found this helpful

Helpful

Anna

Changed my whole view on parenting!

Reviewed in the United States on January 20, 2016

Verified Purchase

I had been a frequent visitor to Janet's Facebook group, and always felt a connection to the type of parenting she describes. Through blogging, I have been trying the past couple years to come up with a type of parenting that encourages critical thinking an emotional intelligence. I strongly believe that teaching a child to think for himself/herself is the best gift we can give them. And Janet's philosophy hit the nail on the head for many aspects I was just stumped on how to approach.

While I had read many of the relevant articles on her Website, Janet suggested that I read this book because it gives an overview of RIE parenting (I love how personal and engaged she is on Facebook!) even though I have a 3-year-old. Most of the book is geared more toward young infants, but the second half of the book is more about toddler discipline. While yes, you can just read the articles on Janet's Website, I still strongly recommend the book because it moves in a very linear fashion and makes a lot more sense than reading a hodgepodge of articles in no particular order (or just the ones you think are relevant to your situation). I feel anybody would be missing out on the whole picture by skipping this book.

The biggest benefit my son and I have gotten from this book is a better and more present relationship- I enjoy his company so much more and when I am with him I am much more focused on the moment. When he was 2 and much easier to distract and keep busy by exploring the house, I had everything under control- dishes were always done, clothes were always washed, dried and put away, and his 7 p.m. bedtime gave me plenty of "me time" to recharge my batteries at the end of the day. Once he turned 3, however, I had almost no time to myself. I was drained every day, he needed constant attention and wanted me to play with him rather than keeping himself busy for a few minutes while I cooked dinner. Bedtime had somehow become 9:30pm instead of 7, and by the time he was finally in bed, I myself went to sleep shortly thereafter. I was unhappy, distracted, and I was having a hard time enjoying his presence much of the time (don't get me wrong, I do love him dearly!). We were both unhappy as a result of all of this, actually.

One of the last chapters in the book talked about self-care and setting/enforcing boundaries. Something just clicked in my head and I realized this was the reason we were both so unhappy. My son needed me to be present - even if it was for short but intense periods of time - and I needed time to recharge on my own. That night, I told him my expectations ahead of time (as Janet suggests throughout the book) and guided him through our bedtime routine. Of course, he resisted and wanted to keep playing with his toys. Whereas I would have usually waited until he as "ready" to avoid a meltdown right before bedtime, I repeated myself once and when he resisted again, I walked to him and took his hand saying "You're having a hard time with putting your toys down to get ready for bed, so I am going to help you." He wasn't too happy at first, but about 10 seconds into the walk to the bathroom he stopped his fussing and actually opened his mouth for me to help brush his teeth. We followed the same procedure for bedtime, and though there were a few hiccups, everything just seemed so much more peaceful. He was in bed by 7:30 that night, and I had plenty of time to myself. We both woke up refreshed and it was probably the best, smoothest morning we'd ever had.

I know this is just the beginning of a journey for us, but Janet has changed my entire outlook on parenting my son and has given me so much hope for the future. I definitely recommend it - and it's such a quick read that even those with only a few short minutes between tantrums can finish it!

48 people found this helpful

Helpful

Natasha E.

A MUST READ FOR PARENTING!

Reviewed in the United States on January 31, 2017

Verified Purchase

Great book, and exactly the parenting relationship I wanted to have with my son. We have an awesome relationship and it just gets better every day. I read "No Bad Kids", another book by Janet, maybe when my son was around 2 and it really helped! There are excerpts from that book in this book as well... And now as I prepare for my 2nd child, this book is just what I needed as I'll be starting from birth. My son is now 4 and he's an active and cooperative participant in our daily routines, a great helper around the house, listens to my instructions and trusts me. If ever he's moody, we know exactly why it is and we are able to talk through it and work it out (whether he needs a nap or is hungry, or something else), but yeah, being able to communicate with him and just honestly enjoy his company every day is such a great blessing. They say life isn't the same when you have kids... this is true, but to me, life is sooo much better now that I have him. I hope that I am able to duplicate the results with the 2nd child as well :)

24 people found this helpful

Helpful

kjespo

Great book to change your perspective - a must read

Reviewed in the United States on April 29, 2015

Verified Purchase

Janet Lansbury is the bomb...hands down. She completely revolutionized my parenting style and her philosophy has brought so much joy into my house. I can honestly say that my 14 month old twins are absolutely delightful kids...all thanks to Janet Lansbury...seriously. By implementing a culture of respect and communication in our house we've created a relaxing and calm environment. I am no longer stressed by my kids expressing their emotions (aka yelling) because I now GET them - it DOES suck that I won't let you kamikaze down the stairs because you really did want to do that. And they are entitled to their range of emotions.

I have seen my kids thrive by using the consistent boundaries recommended by Janet. Let me tell you about the moment that I knew that this philosophy worked: We did baby led weaning and always allowed a lot of freedom with food. When we introduced plates and utensils at about 9 months there was some throwing of the plates, cups, etc.. I would always be really consistent in saying "When you throw your plate it makes me think that you are all done. If you throw your plate again I'm going to take it away." And I would take it away if it happened again. Amazingly, they didn't throw their plates after we did this routine just a few times. But that's not the impressive part. Anyways, fast forward about a month. one of them lifts her plate up, I glance over casually but say nothing, she looks at me, puts her plate down and and makes the sign for "all done". My heart was singing <3 And I wanted to hug Janet because I would not have been smart enough to come up with this on my own :)

One last example - my kids are good sleepers but once in a blue moon they'll be up a few times. Janet's thoughts on telling babies everything that you are going to do have been incredible in this area. If the girls have a hard time going down I will usually go in once or twice to help them resettle. On my first time in I tell them that I will come in once more if they need me. On the second time in, I tell them that I will sing them a song and lay them down, but I am not going to come back in - I will see them in the morning. And - I kid you not - I never have to go back in because they go to sleep. People honestly think that I am a nutter when I suggest this method but they KNOW what you are saying. And they thrive on knowing what to expect.

Anywho - I can't recommend this book enough...it is the single best $11 I have spent on something baby related.

22 people found this helpful

Helpful

Darjeeling

Unequivocally the most valuable parenting tool I have found- teaches true understanding

Reviewed in the United States on March 19, 2018

Verified Purchase

This book is so beautiful. I read if before we had our baby and my husband and I have reread it several times over the last few years, gaining more every time. It teaches us how to gently interact with, listen to, and form cherished bonds with a child from the day they are born. I can say with confidence that the lessons truly "work" and we see the evidence over and over again.
We have purchased more copies as gifts. If I could recommend only one book for any parent of a baby or or youngish child, or parent to be, this book is IT. I recently got rid of a ton of baby and parenting books but you'll never take this one from me!
(Runners up would be Simplicity Parenting by Kim John Payne and Unconditional Parenting by Alfie Kohn, if anyone interested in books in a similar vein but different focus. Also a great bibliography in this book with several more suggestions)

8 people found this helpful

Helpful

Amazon Customer

Would recommend

Reviewed in the United States on March 29, 2021

Verified Purchase

Book was in good condition. I recommend this read to any parent who wants to learn as much as they can about helping their children have a better life. A bit out of my comfort zone due to my own up bringing being very different from the message of this book. Very insightful.

3 people found this helpful

Helpful

ElleTop Contributor: Baby

Small but effective!

Reviewed in the United States on March 6, 2018

Verified Purchase

All of the information in this book can be found online, but I appreciated having it in one, easy-to-reference place. As with any parenting book/philosophy, you have to do what feels right for you—and some of Lansbury’s ideas were a bit too extreme for me, but overall I really enjoy the idea of respectful parenting. My spouse and I went through it essay by essay and it gave us a lot to talk about and consider. We’ve made a lot of changes with how we handle our toddler and it’s been a lot of help! Highly recommend. The book is a lot smaller than I anticipated, though. But that just made it an easy read!

6 people found this helpful

Helpful

Camila Siqueira

Every parent should read this book!

Reviewed in the United States on January 23, 2022

Verified Purchase

I simply love Janet Lansbury’s books. I started with this one, and then read the “No bad kids”, and now I always listen to her podcasts. It helped me to better understand the little ones world and be able to better take care of my son. It gives a different perspective of the child’s behaviors, which helped me to be more patient and understanding.

One person found this helpful

Helpful

Amazon Customer

Impactful and Inspiring!

Reviewed in the United States on May 17, 2014

Verified Purchase

My family had the true honor of attending Janet Lansbury's RIE Parent-Infant Guidance classes for 2 years, and for those two years we had the tremendous privilege of learning from one of the loveliest, most kind-hearted, and most thoughtful teachers ever. In looking back on that experience, we feel like we won the lottery - we are just so immensely thankful to her. Whenever we have moments of parenting doubt, I am reminded of the biggest lesson she taught us: to trust our child. This lesson has always served us well and will continue to serve us throughout our child's life.

While we are no longer able to attend her classes (we graduated almost 2 years ago), we've since been voracious readers of her blog and return again and again to her website for her simple and straightforward but impactful guidance. When we learned that Janet published a book based on her most popular articles, we were thrilled to be able to have them in book form. It will be one of the very few parenting books we hope to pass on to our child, for when she is a parent herself.

We were also thrilled that she can now reach a wider audience of parents like us who needs parenting advice that innately makes sense, feels right and honors who our kids are and who we are as parents. Janet's advice is always clear and concise, and insightful, and above all else, truly respectful of children as authentic and whole beings. It always takes the long view, and helps us remain mindful of our goals of nurturing self-confident, authentic and connected people.

I remember how meticulously and painstakingly she worked to craft these perfect articles. I say perfect, because she chose every word of every sentence and of every thought so carefully and so lovingly, so that in the end, her advice is articulated so beautifully and so meaningfully. This book is a labor of love and it truly shows.

4 people found this helpful

Helpful

Sarah

Easy to read and informative

Reviewed in the United States on March 4, 2021

Verified Purchase

Easy to read and informative. I recommend for all new parents, and it’s a great gift!

3 people found this helpful

Helpful

Need customer service? Click here

‹ See all details for Elevating Child Care: A Guide to Respectful Parenting

5 star		82%
4 star		10%
3 star		5%
2 star		1%
1 star		2%

Elevating Child Care: A Guide to Respectful Parenting

›

Customer reviews

Customer reviews

Elevating Child Care: A Guide to Respectful Parenting

Top positive review

Top critical review

Filtered by

There was a problem filtering reviews right now. Please try again later.

From the United States

There was a problem loading comments right now. Please try again later.

There was a problem loading comments right now. Please try again later.

There was a problem loading comments right now. Please try again later.

There was a problem loading comments right now. Please try again later.

There was a problem loading comments right now. Please try again later.

There was a problem loading comments right now. Please try again later.

There was a problem loading comments right now. Please try again later.

There was a problem loading comments right now. Please try again later.

There was a problem loading comments right now. Please try again later.

There was a problem loading comments right now. Please try again later.

Elevating Child Care: A Guide to Respectful Parenting › Customer reviews

Customer reviews

Elevating Child Care: A Guide to Respectful Parenting

Top positive review

Top critical review

Filtered by

There was a problem filtering reviews right now. Please try again later.

From the United States

There was a problem loading comments right now. Please try again later.

There was a problem loading comments right now. Please try again later.

There was a problem loading comments right now. Please try again later.

There was a problem loading comments right now. Please try again later.

There was a problem loading comments right now. Please try again later.

There was a problem loading comments right now. Please try again later.

There was a problem loading comments right now. Please try again later.

There was a problem loading comments right now. Please try again later.

There was a problem loading comments right now. Please try again later.

There was a problem loading comments right now. Please try again later.

Elevating Child Care: A Guide to Respectful Parenting

›

Customer reviews