Top critical review
Frank, yes; Brian, noooooooooo . . .
Reviewed in the United States on May 23, 2017
Frank Herbert's fragments and alternate scenes from Dune were the real treasure here; and I actually preferred the alternative ending to Dune Messiah than the one published. That said, Brian Herbert's reconstruction of his father's notes are absolutely crap -- fanboy in his mom's basement crap. Yeah, talent is said to skip a generation . . .