Top critical review
3.0 out of 5 starsRun, run, run away...
Reviewed in the United States 🇺🇸 on July 1, 2013
The good news is that the action is back and the old Atticus is back. He's full of wit and more importantly remorse for all the dumb stuff he did that has lead him to this point. Also one long running story line is finally resolved so Atticus and crew have on less nemesis to deal with.
The bad news is something is still missing that I can't quite put my finger on. Atticus is witty again, but not really as fun as he used to be. He did suffer a loss and that could've put a damper on his mood. A lot of this book was spent with Atticus, Granuaile, and Oberon on the run. Which meant there was constant action, but not much character development. I'm not fan of Attuaile or Granicus. There is no real love story there, to me it just seems like "I'm male, you're female, we're both straight, we're on the run and meeting other people is going to be really hard, so we might as well hook up". Don't get me wrong I'm glad has a found a companion and is no longer waxing poetic about his long dead African wife Tahirah, but the Granuaile thing just seemed forced. I know people debate about whether or not men and women can just be friends, but they absolutely can. Especially if one is 2,000 years older than the other and their teacher. I wish they had formed and focused on a familial bond instead of a sexual one.
I'm also glad Atticus finally has a fellow Druid. Although why it took so long is beyond me. I know he has been on the run for millennia, however he did spend a few peaceful centuries with his wife Tahirah. They had 25 children together, some of whom he gave the Imortali-tea to. So why didn't he pass on his Druidic knowledge to any of them, or his grandchildren, or great-grandchildren? He kept close tabs on all of them. Or why not teach Tahirah?
There are only three more books in the series. I hope Mr. Hearne slows down. I don't know if it's him or his publisher but churning out a new book every six months seems to be sucking the charm out of these stories. The seventh book is supposed to come out this year. Hopefully he can slow down, really take his time, and really flesh out the last two books. I'd really hate to see this series go out with a fizzle instead of a bang like so many other Urban Fantasy series have lately.