To calculate the overall star rating and percentage breakdown by star, we don’t use a simple average. Instead, our system considers things like how recent a review is and if the reviewer bought the item on Amazon. It also analyzes reviews to verify trustworthiness.
This book is an excellent collection of technical papers for the professional or advanced amateur. It's sort of a snapshot of the forefront of ornithopod (e.g. Iguanodon, duckbilled dinosaurs, horned dinosaurs) paleontology.
If you don't have a background in paleontology, you'll most likely be happier reading other material. On that note, here are some of my recommendations for easier, less-technical reading that anyone can be happy with: Peter Dodson's "The Horned Dinosaurs"; Farlow and Brett-Surman's "The Complete Dinosaur"; Czerkas and Olson's "Dinosaurs: Past and Present (Vol. 1-2)"; Greg Paul's "The Scientific American Book of Dinosaurs." The first in that list is the only one with a single author (and the only one that really needs to be read straight-through). The rest are collections of stand-alone articles that shouldn't have the reader seeking an outside reference. Also, those compilations include topics beyond just ornithopod dinosaurs. All of those are rather well-illustrated; "Dinosaurs P & P" is the best along those lines. Since Dodson's book is the only one I mentioned as a straight-through read, I feel compelled to mention others, though off-topic: I believe Michael Novacek's "Dinosaurs of the Flaming Cliffs" and "Time Traveler" and Peter Ward's "Gorgon" are all excellent.
Reviewed in the United States on February 26, 2007
Because prospective customers cannot actually browse books on virtual shelves, Amazon.com owes it to its customers to indicate clearly, right up front, the level of technical expertise of the non-fiction books on offer, and most particularly when it is suggesting purchase of books on an 'if you liked this, you'll like that' basis. This is not the first time I have bought a book which turned out to be not what I expected, following one of those 'People who bought this ... also bought this ...' e-mail ads, supposing in the present case that it would be an account for the general reader of the current thinking about a sub-set of the class Dinosauria, what they looked like and how they lived. If the blurb stated that Carpenter was the editor (which would have put me on my guard) rather than the sole author, I missed it. I found I had bought a set of highly technical articles which might have been taken directly from a journal of palaeontology, with titles like 'Teeth of Ornithischian Dinosaurs ..from the Morrison Formation', apparently written for professional palaeontologists and zoologists with a strong background in anatomy. There is no introductory article setting the field in perspective, although there is a very short preface in which the editor hopes "..there is a little of something for everyone" - not for me, a retired academic chemist with a fairly good general knowledge of other sciences - nor is there any attempt to link or correlate the articles. No technical glossary, and no depictions of the living beasts inside the book to match the attractive dust-jacket. Do not buy this book unless you already are an enthusiast for squamous fenestrae and opisthotic-exoccipital sutures.
Il libro raccoglie le ricerche effettuate dalle massime autorità paleontologiche specializzate sulle famiglie di quei dinosauri conosciuti come Ceratopsidi, Ornitopodi e Adrosauri. La materia è trattata in modo molto tecnico ed il libro è consigliato agli appassionati che vogliono approfondire le proprie conoscenze e aggiornarsi sulle scoperte più recenti. Di notevole interesse i capitoli che rivalutano le tesi dei pionieri della paleontologia e i percorsi speculativi che li hanno portati a delle conclusioni oggi smentite. Libro altamente consigliato.