Top critical review
I feel like this series could have been two books instead of three
Reviewed in the United States on January 5, 2020
While I enjoyed reading SUPERNOVA, I really do feel like this series should have been two books. There was so much that happened in SUPERNOVA that I would have liked to see earlier on, likely in ARCHENEMIES, and it would have solved the issue that while ARCHENEMIES was also enjoyable, I didn't feel like enough really happened plot-wise to have it be a book of its own. Thinking about the series overall, I think a lot could have been cut down and condensed into two books. There were also a few moments where the pacing just felt odd, like some really long battle scenes, and I ended up losing focus.
The epilogue was definitely a stunner but... it was another thing that I really wanted to be in the second book and the open-ended question that's leftover could have been resolved in this book. I think that would have added nice depth to the plot and added a nice grab/twist in the second book because I really don't feel like there was much memorable about it, as entertaining as it was. I also wished I had more time to enjoy the contents of the epilogue. To be honest, I really don't want to continue this story any more so I'm actually hoping there ISN'T a spin-off. Not in a bad way, but I feel like a new series wouldn't offer a new enough plot and I don't want to continue the good vs. evil concept in a new series because I feel like too many of the same themes would be repeated.
I didn't really feel like I was waiting for too many answers in SUPERNOVA. I wanted to know what Phobia's backstory was (and we do find out and it is really cool) but that was just about it. Basically I kind of figured there would be a happy ending, which isn't a bad thing, but there were a few things that wrapped up a little too neatly. I felt like for everything that happened, Adrian and Nova ended up being all lovey-dovey a little too easily for all of the secrets and betrayals. There were some cool things that happened in the end to wrap things up but then a couple things unfolded that just felt a little TOO nice and neat. Some of the ending just kind of seemed to nullify the whole series? And start the cycle all over again.
I enjoyed the whole series and I had fun reading it but I don't think it's something I need to reread in the future. I enjoyed the original superhero story and I had fun spending time with these characters but I actually felt like the plot could have been improved upon and it lacked the connection that I've felt with other Marissa Meyer books.