Amazon.com: Customer reviews: The Witness for the Dead (The Cemeteries of Amalo Book 1)
Skip to main content
.us
Hello Select your address
All
Select the department you want to search in
Hello, Sign in
Account & Lists
Returns & Orders
Cart
All
Disability Customer Support Best Sellers Amazon Basics Customer Service New Releases Prime Today's Deals Music Books Amazon Home Registry Fashion Kindle Books Gift Cards Toys & Games Automotive Sell Shopper Toolkit Pet Supplies Computers Pharmacy Coupons Home Improvement Beauty & Personal Care Video Games Luxury Stores Smart Home Health & Household Handmade Audible
Gear up for spring outdoors

  • The Witness for the Dead (The Cemeteries of Amalo Book 1)
  • ›
  • Customer reviews

Customer reviews

4.4 out of 5 stars
4.4 out of 5
1,149 global ratings
5 star
55%
4 star
33%
3 star
9%
2 star
2%
1 star
1%
The Witness for the Dead (The Cemeteries of Amalo Book 1)

The Witness for the Dead (The Cemeteries of Amalo Book 1)

byKatherine Addison
Write a review
How customer reviews and ratings work

Customer Reviews, including Product Star Ratings help customers to learn more about the product and decide whether it is the right product for them.

To calculate the overall star rating and percentage breakdown by star, we don’t use a simple average. Instead, our system considers things like how recent a review is and if the reviewer bought the item on Amazon. It also analyzed reviews to verify trustworthiness.

Learn more how customers reviews work on Amazon
See All Buying Options

Top positive review

All positive reviews›
Joseph L. Crow
5.0 out of 5 starsIf I could give this one seventeen stars, I would.
Reviewed in the United States on June 23, 2021
If I could give this one seventeen stars, I would.
I have been a fan of Addison’s work for ages, and WITNESS FOR THE DEAD justifies that appreciation in stellar fashion. A gem-like combination of intriguing murder mystery and fascinating world building, WITNESS is a rewarding book on many levels.
Othala Celehar is a Witness for the dead, a priest of the god of dreams, moonlight, and death, whose purpose is to bring peace to the unquiet dead, whether by laying hungry ghouls to rest, by passing on last messages to their heirs, or by discovering their murderers and bringing them to justice. He is also a deeply wounded man, still recovering from being forced by his own sense of justice to bear witness against the man he loved for murder, and condemning him to death. He wants nothing more than to perform his calling, to speak for those who can no longer speak for themselves.
In this book, he finds himself entangled in webs of murder, blackmail, and political intrigue, guided through the maze only by his keen wits, priestly skills, and unfailing kindness and compassion. It’s rare to find a protagonist these days whose defining characteristic is decency and compassion, and even rarer to find a tale that allows them to persevere and triumph specifically BECAUSE of that decency and compassion. And that is one of the things I come to Katherine Addison’s Goblin Emperor books for and am never disappointed in, the idea that someone can win by being a good person, that kindness is not weakness, and that it is possible to do the right thing and not be beaten down by a world designed to allow only the cruel and hard to thrive.
I really need to hear that, lately, and I think a lot of folks do. Enjoy.
Read more
27 people found this helpful

Top critical review

All critical reviews›
Excalibur
3.0 out of 5 starsAn okay murder mystery hampered by world building
Reviewed in the United States on July 5, 2021
There are a couple murders and the main one isn’t even the best. The main mystery is solved by Sherlockian/TV procedural “oh we left out this detail, so you could never solve the mystery”. It is a pretty poor resolution to great build up and detective doggedness.

The other big issue is the made up titles, after reading her two books set in the world I still have no idea who is ranked above who. Characters have multiple names, but the made up naming conventions and similarities makes it hard to keep track of who is who. Also the characters randomly drop into archaic “thee, thou” even though they speak “plain English” the rest of the time, with no reasoning to explain why. It feels like people putting on airs, but the writing doesnt support this.

There are Elves and goblins… but that has nothing to do with this story, has no affect, changes nothing and adds nothing.

These are just odd choices I am surprised an editor didn’t help the author resolve.

I enjoyed this story over all and will probably buy the next book set in this world and will be annoyed at the price.
Read more
7 people found this helpful

Search
Sort by
Top reviews
Filter by
All reviewers
All stars
Text, image, video
1,149 global ratings | 99 global reviews

There was a problem filtering reviews right now. Please try again later.

From the United States

Joseph L. Crow
5.0 out of 5 stars If I could give this one seventeen stars, I would.
Reviewed in the United States on June 23, 2021
Verified Purchase
If I could give this one seventeen stars, I would.
I have been a fan of Addison’s work for ages, and WITNESS FOR THE DEAD justifies that appreciation in stellar fashion. A gem-like combination of intriguing murder mystery and fascinating world building, WITNESS is a rewarding book on many levels.
Othala Celehar is a Witness for the dead, a priest of the god of dreams, moonlight, and death, whose purpose is to bring peace to the unquiet dead, whether by laying hungry ghouls to rest, by passing on last messages to their heirs, or by discovering their murderers and bringing them to justice. He is also a deeply wounded man, still recovering from being forced by his own sense of justice to bear witness against the man he loved for murder, and condemning him to death. He wants nothing more than to perform his calling, to speak for those who can no longer speak for themselves.
In this book, he finds himself entangled in webs of murder, blackmail, and political intrigue, guided through the maze only by his keen wits, priestly skills, and unfailing kindness and compassion. It’s rare to find a protagonist these days whose defining characteristic is decency and compassion, and even rarer to find a tale that allows them to persevere and triumph specifically BECAUSE of that decency and compassion. And that is one of the things I come to Katherine Addison’s Goblin Emperor books for and am never disappointed in, the idea that someone can win by being a good person, that kindness is not weakness, and that it is possible to do the right thing and not be beaten down by a world designed to allow only the cruel and hard to thrive.
I really need to hear that, lately, and I think a lot of folks do. Enjoy.
27 people found this helpful
Helpful
Report abuse
    Showing 0 comments

There was a problem loading comments right now. Please try again later.


AmazonAccount685
4.0 out of 5 stars Excellent character work though a bit confusing
Reviewed in the United States on June 29, 2021
Verified Purchase
It's rare these days that a book keeps me interested past the first few chapters. This one kept pulling me back until I have finished it just now at 5:00 am.

This is a mystery novel with several mysteries, all of which are interesting. They are followed in a calm, low-key manner that makes the book rather peaceful to read.

I did have couple of problems with the book. One is that the solutions to the mysteries appear very late in the game, and they end rather abruptly, as if they were never the point and an afterthought. The other is that the characters names and titles caused endless confusion for me. I could only keep two of them straight from a cast of dozens. A glossary would have really helped. I still don't understand the titles.

But the characterization was so great, even with secondary characters, that if they were on the page I recognized them. I didn't have to rely upon the names thank goodness, because they were so very distinct.

This is a story well worth reading I think, for that alone. This one is all about the journey.
9 people found this helpful
Helpful
Report abuse
    Showing 0 comments

There was a problem loading comments right now. Please try again later.


Excalibur
3.0 out of 5 stars An okay murder mystery hampered by world building
Reviewed in the United States on July 5, 2021
Verified Purchase
There are a couple murders and the main one isn’t even the best. The main mystery is solved by Sherlockian/TV procedural “oh we left out this detail, so you could never solve the mystery”. It is a pretty poor resolution to great build up and detective doggedness.

The other big issue is the made up titles, after reading her two books set in the world I still have no idea who is ranked above who. Characters have multiple names, but the made up naming conventions and similarities makes it hard to keep track of who is who. Also the characters randomly drop into archaic “thee, thou” even though they speak “plain English” the rest of the time, with no reasoning to explain why. It feels like people putting on airs, but the writing doesnt support this.

There are Elves and goblins… but that has nothing to do with this story, has no affect, changes nothing and adds nothing.

These are just odd choices I am surprised an editor didn’t help the author resolve.

I enjoyed this story over all and will probably buy the next book set in this world and will be annoyed at the price.
7 people found this helpful
Helpful
Report abuse
    Showing 0 comments

There was a problem loading comments right now. Please try again later.


Dopealope
5.0 out of 5 stars Another perfect Gem
Reviewed in the United States on June 29, 2021
Verified Purchase
"The Goblin Emperor" is without a doubt one of my all time favorite "comfort" reads. I turn to it whenever I just want to escape and become immersed in another world. And the world Katherine Addison built is wonderful. I read a few years back that the author said she did not intend to write a sequel, and that depressed me. But then "The Witness for the Dead" appeared and I was overjoyed. An excellent separate story set in the same world.

If you read this Ms. Addison, please, I beg you, keep writing about this world. It deserves to be thoroughly explored. And thank you, for 2 wonderful novels.
8 people found this helpful
Helpful
Report abuse
    Showing 0 comments

There was a problem loading comments right now. Please try again later.


D
3.0 out of 5 stars Kind of an unsatisying mystery
Reviewed in the United States on September 26, 2021
Verified Purchase
So, full context: this is essentially a sidequel to The Goblin Emperor. I think a number of people picked up the book without realizing that and are super lost since the text assumes that you have some knowledge of the world already set up in the other book, which is really dense. I don't know why the kindle edition of this book doesn't bother to include a glossary; there was one in the first book that was extremely useful and there's enough new terms in this one that it would have been really helpful. I'm still not sure what an ashenoi is (factory worker, maybe?).

If you read Goblin Emperor, don't expect to see many recurring characters at all from the previous book. To get it out of the way, Celehar is really the only connection to the first novel and this is a book that focuses much more on the regular people of the empire. Less court politics, more grubby detective and priest work in Amalo and surrounding communities. It does a decent job of fleshing out more about the world building of the setting, and we get some fun looks at the supernatural as Celehar goes about his job of being a witness for the dead. On that basis alone, it's a good read since we get to step away from the claustrophobic drama of the court.

However, plotwise, I felt it fell a bit flat. Spoilers: the first half of the novel sets up a number of interesting threads/leads about goings on, but the conclusions to a lot of them felt pretty unsatisfying. In particular, the resolution to the main mystery was resolved mostly by a contrived coincidence discovery at a reading of a will that is tied to a totally *different* mystery/investigation and it really didn't have enough build up to this particular conclusion. I literally rolled my eyes at it when I happened because of how coincedental it was. There were some possible resolutions that I felt might have been more interesting (like the marquess, or a patron, or something else from the victim's background) and had better foreshadowing, but the resolution when it comes definitely felt out of nowhere and didn't involve a character we had any real interaction with in the plot before nor any reason to really care about- which I felt would have sold it a lot better. And it wraps up quite quickly when it is finally revealed, which was a bit offputting.

A lot of the book is also pretty repetitive. There's a number of conversations that are meant to be character building but basically fall under "Celehar feels bad about his job and thinks he's an unworthy person or is being a door mat" + "person (who he possibly may have first met a few minutes ago) reassures him that he's better than this and that he's being too self effacing," repeat ad nauseum. His character never really changes and these conversations don't really involve any kind of new exploration, for the most part, so I was left wondering what the point was. It kinda feels like a tumblr post on someone lacking self confidence. Lots of emotional fluffing, but no real substance, no real reflection, and no real change.

I also found some of the characters irritating in how they were portrayed. Zanarim in particular is built up as a villain because she dislikes Celehar and also is pushy and rude during an investigation about an airship explosion. In story, she's shown as uselessly bullying Celehar into interrogating the dead to make sure it wasn't deliberate sabotage and story wise, we're told over and over again that 1) accidents are common in this industry and 2) there's no reason to assume it was sabotage. But, irl, just because accidents are common doesn't somehow mean they shouldn't be investigated and frankly half the point of accident investigations are to see if someone broke protocol or if protocol was insufficient. You have to get safety recommendations from somewhere case wise. *Not* wanting to get to the bottom of it, even if it was just an accident, kind of felt like handwavingly dismissing it as just a fact of life. Like, just because she's wrong doesn't mean it was the wrong thing to do, you know? Nevermind that Zanarim had the clout to possibly bring forward that safety changes needed to be made if that's what happened, she's only ever stated to be an overly ambitious busybody that's mean to Celehar and basically gets sent to solitary confinement for a season after the fact as punishment because she asked Celehar to at least check the testimony of the dead before writing it off as an accident. It just felt like a waste of a possibly interesting and complicated antagonist to a dude who is incredibly saintly in text to the point of it being irritating.
3 people found this helpful
Helpful
Report abuse
    Showing 0 comments

There was a problem loading comments right now. Please try again later.


Mags
3.0 out of 5 stars A good, not great read - unlike the first book
Reviewed in the United States on July 28, 2021
Verified Purchase
I enjoyed the story, which followed Celehar, the Witness for the Dead, identifying the murderer of a beautiful opera singer. That was the main theme, but there were diverts into other death mysteries to be resolved, plus a couple of personal challenges for Celehar to overcome. So there was a mass of characters, all with complicated names - a bit of a reading challenge. I felt the author had put these diverts in because of the "thinness" of the main theme. In this story, Celehar continued to have a hard, joyless life and to suffer intolerance and unfair accusations. These two criticisms were what made it 3 stars for me - moreover, it lacked the touches of humour and possibility of joy that The Goblin Emperor contained. All that seemed possible for Celehar to attain, in the end, was a new, potentially close friendship. Nonetheless I will keep reading these stories, if there are more, because Addison is a superb writer who has created a wonderful world and interesting characters.
3 people found this helpful
Helpful
Report abuse
    Showing 0 comments

There was a problem loading comments right now. Please try again later.


anthony b.
3.0 out of 5 stars Fun, but badly overpriced
Reviewed in the United States on November 24, 2021
Verified Purchase
This book was a decently worthy sequel to the Goblin Emperor, and it was a fast, enjoyable read with great, well-developed characters, classic world building, and mysteries that I really got invested in, but there are just too many problems with it.
1) Too many subplots. For instance, the two side by side mysteries get put on hold for the protagonist login to fight a grave robbing ghoul and then being put on a trial by someone resentful over a decision he made, and then getting involved in treating victims of an airship disaster which was a complete accident. The first of these diversions was decent and bearable, but not the other to.
2) Too little conversations about the events of the last book. There are some good callbacks, and I understand why the author doesn't want to spoil the previous book for new readers, but there was some stuff I was really interesting in hearing other people give their perspectives on that went completely unmentioned.
3) Not enough clues for the main mystery. The solution just kind of gets pulled out of the air at the end, with no real foreshadowing, and then the killer cracks way too easily when there isn't solid evidence.
4) The price. $14.83 on the kindle, with tax to be precise, and even more for a paper copy. This is more of a $7.99 book, maybe $9.99.

While there are parts of this book that I genuinely want to re-read and would have fun doing so, all of the stuff above (especially the price) is too much to ignore, and I don't think I'm going to keep it.
One person found this helpful
Helpful
Report abuse
    Showing 0 comments

There was a problem loading comments right now. Please try again later.


LACE
5.0 out of 5 stars Almost as good as The Goblin Emperor
Reviewed in the United States on August 12, 2021
Verified Purchase
I loved The Goblin Emperor (I've re-read it maybe 5 times), and liked the Angel of the Crows, so I was hoping to like this story as much as The Goblin Emperor. Not quite... but I still loved it. This MC isn't as much of a favorite as the Goblin Emperor for me, and the plot was a little diffuse (side-plots, etc.), but the MC is still compelling and the story interesting. Like the Goblin Emperor, the MC of Witness for the Dead is very much alone, and loneliness is a part of the story. While that was central to the Goblin Emperor, it was more of a backdrop to this story. The MC's past trauma which was discussed in the Goblin Emperor was only hinted at in this story. There wasn't a lot of character growth/development, which was a slight disappointment, but the writing is so good & the story/world so interesting, I shouldn't complain that much.
Helpful
Report abuse
    Showing 0 comments

There was a problem loading comments right now. Please try again later.


Sophia
5.0 out of 5 stars Murder mystery in a steampunk world
Reviewed in the United States on July 26, 2021
Verified Purchase
If you loved "The Goblin Emperor," this book will be your cup of tea. The main character is a minor (though important) character from that novel. Thara Celehar has a high-value, low-motivation job. He is a priest who can sometimes psychically or magically connect with the last thoughts of the recently deceased. Because of his rigid standards of honor and honesty, he is bullied, slandered, and lorded over by ambitious members of the clergy and high-born public. If you enjoy 'hopepunk', this will fit your definition.
PROs: this is an operatic drama set in a fully-developed 19th century world plus goblins and elves.
CONs: definitions and explanations are thin on the ground, elaborate names are thick. You are expected to go with them. I recommend having "The Goblin Emperor" handy - my paperback copy has a glossary.
Helpful
Report abuse
    Showing 0 comments

There was a problem loading comments right now. Please try again later.


sue
5.0 out of 5 stars Like being wrapped in a warm cozy blanket
Reviewed in the United States on July 11, 2021
Verified Purchase
I loved Goblin so much I’ve read it five times. It’s in my top 5 of all time. I was so delighted to hear we were getting a sequel, even if it wasn’t about Maia. While this book is only roughly half the length of the first one, it was still a satisfying 7 hour read for me at my absurdly quick speed, and well worth the digital cover price. I’m sure I’ll come back to it at least once this year.

This wonderfully enjoyable book has a much more gaslight detective novel feel to it as opposed to the cozy mannerpunk tone of GE. Since it takes place out in the city, we get such a wonderful opportunity to see how the common people live. I found it utterly charming to have the nitty gritty details of the elvish society revealed. I found myself smiling with delight with every page. This was such a treat. Thank you, Sarah Monette!
Helpful
Report abuse
    Showing 0 comments

There was a problem loading comments right now. Please try again later.


  • ←Previous page
  • Next page→

Need customer service? Click here
‹ See all details for The Witness for the Dead (The Cemeteries of Amalo Book 1)

Your recently viewed items and featured recommendations
›
View or edit your browsing history
After viewing product detail pages, look here to find an easy way to navigate back to pages you are interested in.

Back to top
Get to Know Us
  • Careers
  • Blog
  • About Amazon
  • Sustainability
  • Press Center
  • Investor Relations
  • Amazon Devices
  • Amazon Science
Make Money with Us
  • Sell products on Amazon
  • Sell apps on Amazon
  • Become an Affiliate
  • Become a Delivery Driver
  • Start a package delivery business
  • Advertise Your Products
  • Self-Publish with Us
  • Host an Amazon Hub
  • ›See More Ways to Make Money
Amazon Payment Products
  • Amazon Rewards Visa Signature Cards
  • Amazon Store Card
  • Amazon Secured Card
  • Amazon Business Card
  • Shop with Points
  • Credit Card Marketplace
  • Reload Your Balance
  • Amazon Currency Converter
Let Us Help You
  • Amazon and COVID-19
  • Your Account
  • Your Orders
  • Shipping Rates & Policies
  • Amazon Prime
  • Returns & Replacements
  • Manage Your Content and Devices
  • Amazon Assistant
  • Help
EnglishChoose a language for shopping.
United StatesChoose a country/region for shopping.
Amazon Music
Stream millions
of songs
Amazon Advertising
Find, attract, and
engage customers
Amazon Drive
Cloud storage
from Amazon
6pm
Score deals
on fashion brands
AbeBooks
Books, art
& collectibles
ACX
Audiobook Publishing
Made Easy
Alexa
Actionable Analytics
for the Web
 
Sell on Amazon
Start a Selling Account
Amazon Business
Everything For
Your Business
Amazon Fresh
Groceries & More
Right To Your Door
AmazonGlobal
Ship Orders
Internationally
Home Services
Experienced Pros
Happiness Guarantee
Amazon Ignite
Sell your original
Digital Educational
Resources
Amazon Web Services
Scalable Cloud
Computing Services
 
Audible
Listen to Books & Original
Audio Performances
Book Depository
Books With Free
Delivery Worldwide
Box Office Mojo
Find Movie
Box Office Data
ComiXology
Thousands of
Digital Comics
DPReview
Digital
Photography
Fabric
Sewing, Quilting
& Knitting
Goodreads
Book reviews
& recommendations
 
IMDb
Movies, TV
& Celebrities
IMDbPro
Get Info Entertainment
Professionals Need
Kindle Direct Publishing
Indie Digital & Print Publishing
Made Easy
Amazon Photos
Unlimited Photo Storage
Free With Prime
Prime Video Direct
Video Distribution
Made Easy
Shopbop
Designer
Fashion Brands
Amazon Warehouse
Great Deals on
Quality Used Products
 
Whole Foods Market
America’s Healthiest
Grocery Store
Woot!
Deals and
Shenanigans
Zappos
Shoes &
Clothing
Ring
Smart Home
Security Systems
eero WiFi
Stream 4K Video
in Every Room
Blink
Smart Security
for Every Home
Neighbors App
Real-Time Crime
& Safety Alerts
 
    Amazon Subscription Boxes
Top subscription boxes – right to your door
PillPack
Pharmacy Simplified
Amazon Renewed
Like-new products
you can trust
   
  • Conditions of Use
  • Privacy Notice
  • Interest-Based Ads
© 1996-2022, Amazon.com, Inc. or its affiliates