Top critical review
Decent, but not that great.
Reviewed in the United States 🇺🇸 on October 5, 2016
As someone who's a horror enthusiast and a sort of 'veteran' of the creepypasta community, I did expect this book to be at least okay, knowing MrCreepyPasta usually has good taste. It may be just because I've been desensitized to such things and haven't been even the slightest unnerved in recent years by so-called "scary" stories, but I was expecting a bit more from this book.
Nowadays when I look at the quality of a scary story, I pretty much treat it as how you would judge any other story- by how engaging it is, how much you want to finish it. None of these stories were bad at all, but I found a few to be on the boring side and almost half of them I had already read.
If you generally enjoy the stories picked by MrCreepyPasta, then you should at least enjoy this book, though somehow it leaves something to be desired.